Is a Costco membership worth it for your household?

A membership only pays if what you save on the shelf beats the fee. Put in what you spend at Costco in a month and roughly how much cheaper it is than where you'd shop otherwise. The math updates as you type.

These are example numbers ($250 a month, 10% cheaper). Type your own over them.

You save on the shelf$300 a year
Gold Star ($65 a year)$235 a year
Executive ($130 a year, 2% back)$230 a year

Gold Star comes out ahead: about $235 a year in your pocket, vs $230 with Executive.

Gold Star pays for itself once you spend about $54 a month at 10% savings.

The three numbers that decide it

The fee. Gold Star is $65 a year. Executive is $130 a year and pays 2% back on most Costco purchases, up to $1,250 a year. Costco lists the purchases that don't earn it, gas among them.

Executive vs Gold Star. The extra $65 comes back once you spend $3,250 a year at Costco — about $271 a month. Below that, Gold Star is the better card. Above it, Executive wins by 2% of everything over that line.

How much cheaper Costco really is for you. This is the number most people guess wrong. Costco is often cheaper per ounce or per roll, but not on everything, and a big pack only saves money if you use it before it goes off. A sale at your supermarket with its store card, or a CVS deal that pays you back in ExtraBucks, can beat the warehouse price on the same item that week.

Getting the real number for your list

Aifford takes your own shopping list and ZIP, checks Costco and the stores near you, and compares every item per unit, so a 30-roll pack and a 6-roll pack are measured fairly. Your plan shows where each item is cheapest with your store cards and memberships counted, and when a Costco pack would be cheaper but you're not a member, it says so — which is exactly the number this calculator asks you to guess.

Price my list First week free, no card needed, then $2.99 a month or $29.99 for the year.

Membership fees and the 2% reward cap are as Costco publishes them on costco.com, checked October 2026. This calculator is an estimate; your savings depend on what you buy.