CVS ExtraCare or myWalgreens: what are the rewards really worth to you?
Both drugstores pay you back in store money, at different rates, and CVS sells a paid tier on top. Put in what you spend at each in a month and how much of it is the store's own brand. The math updates as you type.
How each program pays you back
CVS ExtraCare is free and gives 2% back in ExtraBucks Rewards on qualifying CVS purchases. ExtraBucks are store money: $1 earned is $1 off a later CVS purchase, and they expire, so spend them.
CVS ExtraCare Plus is $5 a month or $48 a year. It adds a $10 reward every month and 20% off CVS Health brand items that aren't already on sale. The $10 rewards alone add up to $120 a year — but only if you go to CVS every month to use them.
myWalgreens is free and gives 1% back in Walgreens Cash on eligible purchases, and 5% on Walgreens brand products. Walgreens Cash comes off a later Walgreens purchase.
The rewards are the small part
A 2% reward on a toothpaste that costs a dollar more than at Walmart is still a loss. The bigger money at drugstores is in the weekly deals — buy-one-get-one, "spend $20 get $5 back" — and those change every week. Aifford takes your own list and ZIP, checks this week's deals at CVS, Walgreens and the other stores near you, counts the rewards you'd earn, and shows where each item is really cheapest.
Price my list First week free, no card needed, then $2.99 a month or $29.99 for the year.
Program rates and fees as CVS and Walgreens publish them on cvs.com and walgreens.com, checked October 2026. Some purchases don't earn rewards (CVS excludes prescriptions, among others); this calculator is an estimate.
Also see: Is a Costco membership worth it? · Walmart+ or Instacart+?