Grocery delivery or the store: what does delivery really cost you?
The delivery fee is only one line. Item prices in delivery apps are often higher than on the shelf, and there's a service fee and a tip on top. Put in a typical order and the trip you'd make instead. The math updates as you type.
Where the extra money goes
Item prices. On Instacart each store sets its own prices, and many charge more than on their shelves; some stores say their prices match in-store, and the store page tells you which. In a December 2025 test, Consumer Reports and the Groundwork Collaborative found identical Instacart baskets priced about 7% apart on average, and single items up to 23% apart. Instacart ended those price tests later that month — but a markup over the shelf is still common.
Fees. Delivery fees start around $3.99 on larger orders and climb for small or rushed ones. The service fee is a share of the order and varies by store and order size. Delivery run by the store itself (Walmart, Target, CVS) has its own fees and order minimums, so it's worth pricing the same basket there too.
The tip. It goes to the shopper, and it's real money in the comparison. Leave it in.
The trip. 12¢ a mile is gas only, at about $3.10 a gallon and 25 miles a gallon. If you'd count wear on the car too, the IRS rate is much higher, so raise the miles to match.
The cheapest answer is usually a mix
Most households don't need all-delivery or all-store. Aifford takes your own list and ZIP, prices every item at the stores near you and online, adds each delivery service's fees with your memberships counted, and shows the cheapest one-stop, two-stop and delivered options side by side — so you see what delivery costs you on your list, not an average.
Price my list First week free, no card needed, then $2.99 a month or $29.99 for the year.
Fee levels as Instacart and delivery-fee guides describe them, checked October 2026; price-test figures from Consumer Reports and the Groundwork Collaborative, December 2025. Fees change by store, order size and time slot; this calculator is an estimate.
Also see: Walmart+ or Instacart+? · Is a Costco membership worth it? · CVS or Walgreens rewards?